The COVID-19 pandemic has changed not only routines of daily life but also some of our thinking about the nation’s problems, a Penn State Mood of the Nation Poll finds.
A significant number of people are fearful of activities they took for granted before the pandemic. We asked about seven activities. Ninety-seven percent of our respondents expressed having more fear about at least one of the activities. For example, forty-two percent have become more fearful of receiving mail and packages at home, and for thirty-eight percent, eating take home food and interacting with teens and young people became more frightening.
The survey was conducted April 27-30, when about 30,000 new cases and 2,000 deaths were being reported each day (the maximum margin of sampling error is ± 4% for analyses of the entire sample).
At the opposite end of the spectrum, relatively few people were afraid to touch objects in their own home (eleven percent) or take a walk in their neighborhood (seventeen percent). There is no evidence that the coronavirus can spread through food, and objects received in the mail are no more dangerous than surfaces in the home. But the poll shows that most Americans feel that familiar places and objects are less threatening than bringing new things into their homes, whether mail or an order of food.
In the middle, about one in five feared interacting with Asian people and being around family members. Perhaps the idea of interacting with family members also raised potential threats of people coming from different places with different pandemic avoidance practices.
Some respondents’ fear of Asian people no doubt grew from the emphasis by the press and administration, in the beginning especially, on the origins of the virus in Wuhan China. Numerous Americans of Asian descent told stories of hostile remarks and even some physical violence against them.
Though we expected that those in areas of the highest incidence of COVID-19would be the most fearful, we did not find many significant differences between those who lived in a county in the top ten percent of COVID-19 cases per 100,000 and those who did not. The exceptions were fear of taking a walk in the neighborhood and receiving packages and other deliveries into ones’ homes. There, possible exposure to the virus from other community members led those in areas of high COVID-19incidence to be more fearful.
A person’s partisan stance shaped these feelings of fear, though almost everyone of every partisan persuasion expressed at least one fear. We expected that Republicans would be less fearful than Democrats because the president downplayed the importance and severity of the pandemic.
The chart below shows that this expectation is correct with one notable exception. Though Republicans (red bars) are less fearful than Democrats (blue bars) of bringing things into their houses and interacting with family members and with teenagers, they are just as fearful of Asian people. It is likely that the president’s blame of China has more resonance with Republicans than others, and, despite the fact that they believe that the virus is not as virulent as other Americans think, they are more influenced by the blame placed on China.
Independents fall between Democrats and Republicans in their fear of these daily activities. Sometimes they are closer to the Democratic levels (as with receiving packages and mail and eating take out), other times they are closer to the Republicans (as with interacting with teenagers and being around family).
The survey was done in the last days of April before the pandemic had hit Republican areas of the country hard. We checked to see if partisan differences reflected COVID-19 incidences or were independent of them. We found that partisan differences remained high in areas of the country not yet afflicted with high incidences of COVID-19.
In the counties where the incidence was in the top quarter, partisan differences diminished in a few cases although highly significant differences did persist in fear of interacting with teens, bringing deliveries into the home, interacting with family, and walking in the neighborhood. For most of the areas of potential fear, Republicans and especially Independents were more fearful than those in lower incidence areas, but still less fearful than Democrats.
The pandemic has changed people’s attitudes toward their normal day-to-day activities, but it has also changed some people’s minds about political issues.
We asked our respondents whether or not they saw as problems three issues concerning the workings of our government itself, including barriers to voting, the government’s capacity to respond to major emergencies, and Americans’ inability to work together to solve problems; and three “kitchen table” issues, including the percentage of the public who lack health care, the low federal minimum wage, and the number of Americans who are always been one paycheck away from financial crisis.
Respondents could respond that the issue “was not a problem at all,” “was “somewhat serious,” or was a “very serious problem.” We asked people whether they thought the issue was a serious problem today and whether their opinion had changed since before the pandemic.
For each of the issues, more respondents were likely to see the problems as very serious after the pandemic than before. The change was largest in the twelve percent increase in the proportion believing that the number of Americans living paycheck to paycheck was a serious problem and the eleven percent increase in the proportion of those who thought that the government’s capacity to respond to major emergencies was a serious problem. There was also a nine percent increase in the proportion of our respondents who believed that Americans’ inability to work together to solve major problems was a serious issue.
The difficult time that Americans have had during the COVID pandemic did highlight both the economic problems of many Americans and the problems that the government has had in marshaling resources and citizen support to fight the pandemic.
Of course, partisanship shapes views on these and most public policy issues. Table 3 shows responses to three of these items looking separately at Republicans, Democrats, and Independents. The graph shows, for each item, the proportion who believed the problem was very serious before the pandemic and the proportion who believed the problem was very serious when the survey was done. Overall, the average increase in the proportion who thought each problem was very serious was six percent for Republicans, nine percent for Independents, and ten percent for Democrats.
The two issues that led the list of what Republicans judged to be very serious problems were the inability of Americans to work together to solve problems, where during the pandemic 52 percent of Republicans thought this was a serious problem, and the fact that many Americans live paycheck to paycheck, which 45 percent thought was a serious problem. We can see that Republicans increased their belief that failure to work together is a serious problem more than those in the other two groups, indicating that the pandemic may have had slightly more impact on their thinking about this aspect of government. Even taking that increase into account, Democrats and Independents are more likely to see this as a problem than are Republicans.
All three groups had about the same increase in concern about Americans living paycheck to paycheck. Overall, more Democrats see this as a serious problem than Independents, and more Independents are concerned than are Republicans.
After the issue of living paycheck to paycheck, Democrats were the most concerned about the percentage of the public who lack health care, which 78 percent of Democrats labeled a serious concern. Table 3 indicates that Republicans’ views about the seriousness of that issue did not change before and after the beginning of the pandemic. The biggest change was among Independents. Fifteen percent more Independents saw it as a serious problem in April compared to before the pandemic.
The global pandemic has made millions of Americans sick and cost the lives of more than 150,000. It has resulted in millions losing jobs and as early as May caused 100,000 business to shut down. But the less dramatic impacts on day to day living have may have major consequences as well.
Living in fear of infection from food, objects and strangers is the kind of daily stressor that can have long term consequences for mental and physical health. And the increasing concern for those living paycheck to paycheck and for those lacking health insurance can have downstream consequences for the upcoming election and the kinds of policies that will be a priority when the pandemic is past.
At the same time, though Americans are suffering together, there is no sign that it has brought their outlook and opinions closer together.